News That Matters


European Climate Aspirations and Agricultural Protests: A Dual Crisis

The European Union's ambitious climate goals and the ongoing farmer protests across the continent intersect at a crucial junction - the struggle for a sustainable future and the pressing economic realities of the present.

The European Commission, under the leadership of EU Commissioner for Climate Action Wopke Hoekstra, recently proposed a significant goal to cut carbon emissions by 90% by 2040 from 1990 levels. This initiative, which aims to supersede the current 55% emissions reduction target for 2030, was outlined in a comprehensive roadmap encompassing sectors like fossil fuels, transportation, and industry. However, this target is pending approval by the European Parliament.

The forthcoming European Parliament elections in June could potentially influence the implementation of the 90% target. Particularly, if the European Greens lose seats to conservative and far-right parties, this could stall the EU's climate goals, as these parties may resist increased regulation and aim to dismantle aspects of the EU's Green Deal.

Farmers across Europe, from Spain to Italy and France to Germany, have voiced significant opposition to the EU's climate goals. Their protests, marked by road blockages, large demonstrations, and even the hurling of eggs and stones at the European Parliament, demand more flexibility from the EU, stricter controls on non-EU produce, and increased government support. Their grievances stem from high production costs, stringent EU regulations, particularly the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), and environmental and sanitary regulations that non-EU producers are exempt from, enabling them to sell cheaper produce.

Extreme weather conditions such as droughts in Spain and Italy have compounded the farmers' struggles, affecting harvests and driving up prices. Catalonia even declared a state of emergency due to a record-breaking three-year drought. The protests have also caused significant disruptions to road traffic and supply chains, with supermarket chain Colruyt in Belgium reporting blockages at three of its distribution centres, and French transport firms losing about 30% of their revenue due to the protests.

Governments have responded to the farmers' concerns. French Prime Minister Gabriel Attal announced plans for France to become self-reliant in food and tighten import controls, and also pledged to cease imposing stricter regulation on its farmers than EU regulations mandate. The French government also announced emergency measures for the sector costing €400 million, plus €200m in cash advances. In Germany, opposition leader Friedrich Merz and the state premiers of six German states expressed solidarity with the farmers, criticizing the government's plans to cut agricultural subsidies.

The farmer protests and the climate goals are not necessarily mutually exclusive. As Linda Kalcher, the executive director of Strategic Perspectives, points out, newly elected conservative or far-right lawmakers could support some ambitious climate policies due to their economic and security benefits.

In conclusion, the EU is at a pivotal juncture. It must balance its aspiration for a sustainable future with the immediate economic realities of its farming community. The political dynamics at play and the forthcoming European Parliament elections in June will undoubtedly play a significant role in this balancing act.